Key facts
- The four links in the main menu labelled as services each led to a portfolio gallery page with two short paragraphs of copy beneath the photos.
- No page on the site described a service in the words a homeowner types, such as kitchen remodel or home addition plus the town, and no town pages existed for either of the two counties the company serves.
- The site's SEO score in Lighthouse was a perfect 100, which measures technical basics and says nothing about whether the pages answer the search.
- Photos of finished work are the strongest asset a contractor has, and the fix kept every gallery and added the missing service pages beside them.
- The pattern is common on sites built by designers for visual impact: the portfolio becomes the navigation and the words that earn the search never get written.
The finding
The company's navigation offered four services. Clicking any of them opened a page of project photos with two paragraphs of text under the gallery. There was no page that explained what a kitchen and bath project involves with this contractor, what an addition costs to plan, how long a renovation takes, or which towns in the two counties the crew works in. The portfolio was doing the job of the service pages, and it cannot.
What we looked at
We opened every link in the main menu and recorded where it went and how many words of body text the destination carried. We searched the site for pages containing the service phrases a homeowner uses and found none beyond the gallery captions. We checked the sitemap for town or county pages and found none. We ran Lighthouse on mobile, which returned a perfect SEO score beside a slow performance score, and we read the contact page, where the only project-review form sat with twelve fields.
Why it mattered for leads
A homeowner planning a kitchen searches kitchen remodel plus a town, reads two or three contractor pages that describe the process, the timeline and the kind of budget involved, and then looks at photos. A gallery with two paragraphs ranks for nothing, because there is nothing on it to rank, and it converts poorly for the visitor who arrives from a referral, because it answers none of the questions that come before a call. The company's real strength, decades of finished projects, was invisible to search and unexplained to the visitor.
False positive checks we ran
We checked whether the service text might be rendered by script and missing from the fetched HTML; it was not, the pages simply had two paragraphs. We checked whether separate service pages existed but were not linked from the menu; the sitemap showed none. We checked whether the gallery pages carried enough text in image captions or alt attributes to count; they did not. We confirmed the finding was not a mobile-only menu problem by reading the desktop navigation, which pointed to the same galleries.
The fix
The proposal kept every gallery and added one page per service, written for the search a homeowner uses, with the process, the timeline, what the first conversation covers and a short project-review form on the page itself. It added town pages for the two counties with real local substance rather than a swapped name, and it moved the reviews, which had been rendered inside an embedded frame, into the page as text. The galleries were linked from each service page as proof, which is the job they are good at.
How to check your own site for this
Open your main menu and click each service. Count the words on the destination page below the photos; if it is under two hundred and none of them describe the process or the area served, you have a gallery, not a service page. Search your own site for the phrase a customer would type for that service plus your town; if nothing comes back, neither will Google. Keep the photos and write the page, one per service, with a way to ask a question on it.
Related questions
No. They are the proof. The problem is using them as the only page for a service, with no words that describe the work, the area or the process. Keep the gallery and add the page.
Lighthouse's SEO score checks technical basics such as titles, meta descriptions and crawlability. It does not judge whether a page answers a search, so a two-paragraph gallery can score perfectly and rank for nothing.
Long enough to answer what the homeowner asks before calling: what the service covers, how a project starts, roughly how long it takes, and where you work. That is usually several hundred words plus a form, with the gallery linked as proof.
Yes, when each town page carries real local substance, such as the kinds of homes there, permit realities and completed projects nearby. A page with only the town name swapped is worse than no page.
Speed was a separate finding on the same site, a nine-second largest contentful paint, and was addressed by rebuilding the site rather than by the service pages themselves.
an anonymized finding from a real proposal audit; the business is described by type only; SearchPod sells the services that fix findings like this.
Want your site audited the same way?
Get a free, no-obligation proposal within one business day. We look at your site and your market and tell you plainly what we would do, and what we would not.
Get your free proposal