Skip to content

Decision path 9 min read Updated September 23, 2026

You're making your first marketing hire or hiring your first agency. What should you check first?

In short

Before hiring anyone, inventory what accounts you actually own, GA4, Google Ads, Search Console, and Google Business Profile, and confirm you have admin access to each yourself. Record today's baseline numbers so you can judge improvement honestly later, and settle who owns the accounts and data in writing before work starts.

Key facts

  • A business is entitled to hold admin level access to its own Google Ads, GA4, Search Console, and Google Business Profile, and confirming that access exists in the owner's own login, not only an agency's, is worth doing before any work begins, not after a relationship ends.
  • Recording a simple baseline snapshot, current monthly leads, current organic traffic, current ad spend and cost per lead, before hiring gives a real number to compare against later, rather than relying on memory or a report written by the same party being judged.
  • A written agreement that states the business owns its own website, ad accounts, Google Business Profile, and customer data protects against a difficult and sometimes costly account recovery process later if the relationship ends.
  • Google Ads has a public minimum useful spend, and an account funded below that floor rarely gathers enough data to optimize well, which is worth knowing before agreeing to a budget too thin to ever show a fair result.
  • SEO work typically needs a full billing cycle, often several, before a fair read on results is possible, so agreeing on a realistic evaluation timeline in advance avoids judging too early or too late.

Check What You Actually Own Before Anyone Else Touches It

List every account relevant to marketing that the business already has: GA4, Google Ads, Search Console, Google Business Profile, and any CRM or email platform in use. For each one, confirm whether you personally have admin access under your own login, not a login controlled by someone else.

If an account doesn't exist yet, create it under a login the business controls before handing it to a hire or an agency to manage, rather than letting them create and control it from the start.

Record Today's Numbers Before You Can't Remember What 'Before' Looked Like

Write down current monthly lead count, current organic traffic, current ad spend and its cost per lead, and current Google Business Profile calls and direction requests, pulled from the platforms directly. This becomes the number you compare against later.

Without a real baseline, any future claim of improvement rests on memory or on a report from the very party whose performance you're trying to judge, which is a weak position to evaluate from.

Settle Who Owns the Accounts and Data Before Work Starts

Get it in writing that the business, not the hire or the agency, owns the website, the ad accounts, the Google Business Profile, and the customer data collected through them. This single point prevents one of the most common and disruptive problems when a marketing relationship ends badly.

This is a normal, reasonable request, and hesitation to agree to it is worth treating as information about how the relationship is likely to go later.

Check That the Budget You're Planning Can Actually Work

If starting with paid search, check whether the planned budget clears the minimum level a channel needs to gather enough data to optimize well. A budget set too thin to ever show a fair result leads to an unfair judgment of the channel itself, not just the person running it.

If the budget can't clear that floor yet, it's reasonable to start with the free groundwork, a complete Google Business Profile and basic tracking, and grow into paid spend once the budget can support it properly.

Agree on a Fair Evaluation Timeline Before You Need One

Decide upfront how long the hire or agency gets before a first real evaluation, ideally a full billing cycle for paid work and longer for SEO. Put this in writing alongside the ownership terms, so neither side is negotiating the timeline itself in the middle of a disagreement about results.

Related questions

Not sure which step you are on?

Get a free, no-obligation proposal within one business day. We look at your site and your market and tell you plainly what we would do, and what we would not.

Get your free proposal

Keep reading

More in Decision paths

All 15 in Decision paths