Key facts
- Local SEO ranking depends heavily on your Google Business Profile (categories, services, photos, and reviews) alongside your website, so an RFP that only mentions website changes is missing half the actual work.
- Google's map pack ranking uses proximity to the searcher, so no amount of optimization moves a business into a map pack for a city or neighborhood it is not actually located in or close to; an honest bidder will tell you this rather than promise it away.
- NAP consistency, your business name, address, and phone number matching exactly across your website, Google Business Profile, and directory listings, is a known ranking factor, and it is a checklist item a bidder should be able to audit, not a vague promise.
- Review velocity, the rate at which new reviews come in, is something an agency can support with a request system but cannot fabricate; the RFP should ask how the bidder generates real reviews, since fake or incentivized reviews violate Google's policies and put your listing at risk.
- A single-location business usually needs far fewer location pages than a multi-branch business, so a bidder quoting a large page-count package for a one-address business should be asked to justify what those pages are for.
Scope boundaries
State the exact address or addresses this work covers, and the service area if you serve customers beyond your physical location (a plumber who drives to customers, for example, versus a retail store customers walk into). This distinction changes how the map pack and service-area settings on your Google Business Profile should be configured.
State which parts of local SEO are in scope: Google Business Profile management, on-site local pages, citation building and cleanup on directories, and review generation support. A bidder should quote each piece separately if you want the option to handle some in-house, for example if you already manage your own review requests.
State your current visibility as a starting point, whether you already show in the map pack for your core search terms or are starting from nothing, since the work and the realistic timeline differ substantially between improving an existing presence and building one from scratch.
What the vendor must be given
Set the vendor up as a manager on your Google Business Profile through Google's own profile management tools, so you remain the primary owner and can remove their access without losing the profile. Never let a vendor create or claim your profile under an account only they control.
Give the vendor access to your website's CMS if location or service pages will be added or edited, and to GA4 and Search Console so they can see which local searches are already sending traffic and which are not.
Supply your current list of business directory listings if you have one (Yelp, industry-specific directories, chamber of commerce sites), and any existing reviews or customer feedback you have collected, so the vendor is not starting a citation audit from zero.
Ownership and exit clauses
State that you remain the primary owner of your Google Business Profile at all times, with the vendor added as a manager, and that this cannot be changed without your written approval. Losing control of your own Business Profile to a vendor is one of the most damaging things that can happen to a local business's online presence.
State that any citation listings created on directories during the engagement are created in your business's name with your contact details as the verified owner where the platform allows it, not the vendor's agency account, so those listings remain useful after the vendor relationship ends.
The contract should say plainly that the vendor owes you a full list of every directory where a citation was created or corrected, along with login credentials for any of those platforms, on termination, so you or a new vendor can maintain them going forward.
Milestones and acceptance tests
Set an onboarding milestone: a written audit of your current Google Business Profile completeness (categories, services, photos, hours) and a citation scan showing where your NAP is inconsistent across the web, delivered in the first two to four weeks.
Set a 60 to 90 day milestone with a specific test: your Google Business Profile is fully complete against the audit's checklist, the top citation inconsistencies found in the audit are corrected, and you have a written baseline of your map pack visibility for your core search terms to compare against going forward.
Set a recurring quarterly milestone comparing map pack visibility and review count against the prior quarter's baseline, since local SEO improvement is measured over months, not the first few weeks, and a written trend line is a better acceptance test than any single snapshot.
Scoring rubric
The audit and how honest the timeline sounds should carry the most weight here: score the written Google Business Profile and citation audit at 30 percent, price at 25 percent, local experience in a comparable market or category at 20 percent, the review generation approach at 15 percent, and references at the remaining 10 percent.
Score honesty about timeline explicitly: a bidder promising map pack rankings within a few weeks for a competitive local category should score lower, not higher, since that promise is either unrealistic or relies on tactics that risk your listing.
Score review generation on process, not promised volume: ask how the bidder helps you request reviews from real customers (a follow-up text or email system, for example) rather than any method that offers incentives for reviews, which violates Google's policies.
Questions every bidder must answer
Make every bidder answer in writing: What specifically will you do to my Google Business Profile in the first 30 days? How do you find and fix citation inconsistencies across the web? What is a realistic timeline to see movement in the map pack for my specific city and category, and why?
Also ask: How do you generate reviews, and do you ever offer incentives for them? Will I remain the primary owner of my Google Business Profile throughout the engagement? What happens to my citations and profile access if this relationship comes to an end?
A bidder who gives a specific, bounded timeline and describes review generation as a request system rather than an incentive program is describing compliant, sustainable work. A bidder who promises fast rankings without qualifying the competitiveness of your category is a warning sign.
Related questions
It depends heavily on how competitive your city and category are, but most local SEO work needs a few months before map pack movement becomes visible, and longer in dense, competitive markets. Ask each bidder to give you a range specific to your situation rather than a single number.
It can be, if you serve customers within a defined service area and Google allows a service-area business profile for your category. The approach differs from a storefront business, so make sure the bidder addresses this specifically rather than treating every business the same.
A citation is any online listing of your business name, address, and phone number, on directories like Yelp or industry sites. Inconsistent citations confuse search engines about which details are correct, which is why citation cleanup is a standard local SEO task.
Some of it, yes, especially the Google Business Profile setup and review requests. Citation cleanup across dozens of directories and ongoing monitoring is where most business owners run out of time, which is usually the part worth outsourcing first.
Yes. A local engagement is billed the same way we bill everything else, $50 a page once you pass 10 pages a month, nothing charged to set up, and every project guaranteed for its first 30 days. The Business Profile audit and quarterly visibility check this pack calls for are what a client would actually get.
SearchPod is a vendor for this kind of work and would answer this RFP; the acceptance tests here are the ones we agree to.
Want this scoped and priced for your business?
Get a free, no-obligation proposal within one business day. We look at your site and your market and tell you plainly what we would do, and what we would not.
Get your free proposal